IIT Kharagpur

Dedicated to the service of the Nation.

Rajiv Gandhi School of Intellectual Property Law

Education is what remains after one has forgotten what one has learned in school - Albert Einstein.

Law

Share your knowledge. It is a way to achieve immortality - Dalai Lama XIV.

Justice

Justice will not be served until those who are unaffected are as outraged as those who are - Benjamin Franklin.

Law and Society

There can be no place in a 21st-century parliament for people with15th-century titles upholding19th-century prejudices - Baron Ashdown.

Search This Blog

Sunday, 7 December 2014

Legal News Updates

We bring you the updates for last week. Hope it updates you with all the news from legal world.



Updates: 23rd November to 07 November 2014.

The Supreme Court has constituted a Special Bench christened ‘Social Justice Bench’ to achieve the Constitutional  goal of securing ‘social justice for the citizens of the country. The bench comprising of Justice Madan B Lokur and Justice UU Lalit will hear all cases in the Supreme Court falling within the domain of “social justice”. The Bench will start functioning from December 12 and will sit at 2 pm on every Friday.

The Centre is planning to partially open up legal market to foreign firms. According to the proposal put forward by the Centre, foreign lawyers could be permitted to practice in India in conjunction with Indian lawyers, as a joint venture, with a cap on foreign participation. Also, advisory or non-litigious services in Indian law could be opened up subject to foreign lawyers going through a prequalification examination in various aspects of Indian law. However, the Bar Council of India and Society of Indian Law Firms (SILF) have voiced their opposition to this proposal.

The Delhi High Court refused to quash the FIR filed against three men who tried to molest a Delhi Police Constable. The woman registered an FIR against the three persons, who incidentally lived in her locality only. She later agreed to take back her complaint, after the intermediation of some people. When the matter reached the Delhi High Court for quashing of FIR, Justice Pratibha Rani, refusing to quash the FIR said, ‘if a woman police officer can’t walk on the street what will happen to common girls?’

The Union Cabinet, chaired by the Prime Minister has approved the introduction of the Companies (Amendment) Bill, 2014 in Parliament to make certain amendments in the Companies Act, 2013. The Companies Act, 2013 (Act) was notified on 29.8.2013. Out of 470 sections in the Act, 283 sections and 22 sets of Rules corresponding to such sections have so far been brought into force. In order to address some issues raised by stakeholders such as Chartered Accountants and professionals, some amendments have been proposed.

The Allahabad High Court dismissed a PIL challenging Rule 7 of the recently released Bar Council of India Rules, 2014. Under Rule 7, a lawyer must practice for two years in a trial court and three in a high court before being allowed to practice before the apex court. It was dismissed not on merits, but on the ground that Rule 7 has still not been notified and therefore it would be an exercise in futility if the petition is examined on merits.

The Delhi High Court has held that the Competition Commission of India (CCI) has the right to file an appeal in cases where its probes have been stayed by courts. The order came after a CCI appeal in a dispute involving JCB India Ltd, in which all CCI proceedings, including the probe, were stayed by the HC after its director general raided JCB’s premises. Doubts were raised whether CCI could file such an appeal, as it was the CCI that ordered the probe against JCB in the first place; the court ruled that CCI has the right. The court also held that “the interference by us at this stage is unwarranted”. It asked both parties to raise their issues before the single judge who is hearing the case.

The Delhi High Court recently interpreted S.107A expansively to conclude that it is applicable when a party exports a patented product to a third party outside India as long as the purpose of export is the facilitation of research. The case relates to the Compulsory License granted by the Court to Natco for the compound Sorafenib tosylate. One of the conditions was that Natco should use the licensed product “solely for the purpose of making, using, offering for sale and selling the drug covered by the patent for the purpose of treating HCC and RCC in humans within the territory of India”. However, Bayer found that Natco was exporting the product outside India. In March this year, an interim order was passed by the Delhi High Court preventing Natco from such export. The present application was filed by Natco to seek permission from the Court to export 1 kilogram of Sorafenib to a Chinese Pharmaceutical Company for preparation of a trial batch of the generic drug in China.


The application filed by Venus Remedies Ltd. (the applicant) for an invention titled “Parenteral Composition Comprising Ceftriaxone and Vancomycin for Bacterial Resistance and Process of Preparation Thereof” was opposed in a pre grant opposition by (Akums Drugs & Pharmaceuticals) on the grounds of lack of inventive step as required under Section 2(1)(j), 2(1)(ja) and 2(1)(l) and also on the grounds of section 3(d) and 3(e) of the Patent Act. The opposition, however, was not successful. The invention was a single unit combination of two incompatible antibiotics (Ceftriaxone and Vancomycin) which are combined together with stabilizing agents, such as L-arginine, EDTA and Na2CO3.  The Controller observed that the claimed invention was held not to be a mere aggregation of property/features since Ceftriaxone and Vancomycin are made compatible, due to the existence of a chemical stabilizing and solubizing agent. The opponent also contended that various studies have shown the concomitant use of vancomycin and ceftriaxone and cited two documents.  However, both these documents failed to form ‘prior art’ because they were published on 3/3/2006 and 20/12/2005 after the filing of the present patent application in 14/2/2005. Moreover, the prior art failed to contemplate the problem of incompatibility between Ceftriaxone and Vancomycin. Also, the contention on Section 3(d) was dismissed on the ground that nothing in the prior art qualified as a “known substance” and hence Section 3(d) was not attracted.  The Controller declared that that the invention was both a technical advance as well as economically significant and therefore qualified the inventiveness criteria.

We hope that this summarizes the last week's News. Your comments and suggestions are welcomed.
Until next post of weekly News updates.

Anjana Srinivasan, (2nd Year student of IIT Kharagpur Law School)

For 'OFF Court.'

Disclaimer: This blog or any post thereof is not to be considered to be in any way associated with the official stand of IIT kharagpur or RGSOIPL on the issues being discussed in the said post. The opinions on the blog are the authors own and should not be considered as legal advice.

Sunday, 23 November 2014

Legal News Updates

We bring you the updates for last week. Hope it updates you with all the news from legal world.


Updates: 03rd November to 22nd November 2014.
In an interim order passed by the Delhi High Court, Micromax has to pay a royalty that amounts up to 1% of the selling price of its devices to Ericsson. Ericsson had alleged that Micromax had refused to enter into a licensing agreement covering its patented innovations across several wireless technology standards such as GSM, EDGE and third generation (3G). The patents in question are a part of what are called “standards-essential” patents and holders are expected to license them on Free Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory (FRAND) terms. Micromax was said to have keen on negotiating a FRAND license with Ericsson but the companies could not come to a suitable conclusion.

The E-Committee of the Supreme Court has rejected the Government’s proposal to record the Court proceedings in a subordinate court.  The E-Committee rejected the proposal saying it was not acceptable at present. The proposal to record court proceedings was made by the government after an advisory council meeting of the Law Ministry held in August this year. This was as a part of the E-court project under which the government had sought to initiate recording of the proceedings in lower courts and subsequently bring the High Courts and the Supreme Court under its ambit.

The Supreme Court is facing an interesting case of murder where the accused was tried as an adult though the accused was a juvenile at the time of commission of offence.  Since, the accused was a juvenile when the offence was committed, the criminal trial stands vitiated and a fresh trial will have to be held before the Juvenile Justice Board (JJB).  The Court has sought the assistance of the Attorney General to resolve the issue.

In a letter to the High Courts, Chief Justice of India H.L. Dattu has asked for the judgments delivered by the Judges of the High Courts, in order to “ascertain quantitative as well as qualitative disposal of cases”. So far Reported Judgments have been accepted as one of the parameters for ascertaining “qualitative disposal”. Now as per this letter, the details of all judgments will have to be provided. The letter also demands resumes of the Chief Justices and the Judges in a specified format. It also demands details of total and reported judgments.

In Criminal writ petition before the Bombay High Court, the Petitioner was seeking criminal prosecution of a Judge in respect of acts discharged during judicial functions. It was held no Court shall entertain or continue any civil or criminal proceeding against a Judge for any act, thing or word committed, done or spoken by him, when, or in the course of, acting or purporting to act in the discharge of his official or judicial duty or function. The Court also held that no Judge can be prosecuted without a prior sanction, whether the alleged offence is punishable under the provisions of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 or under the Indian Penal Code or under any other law.

The Central Information Commission has held that refusing to give details of foreign tours by ministers and officers, and staff particulars of AG without hearing the appellant was wrong.  It set aside the order of First Appellate Authority of Department of Legal Affairs as it was given without hearing the appellant.  CIC also recommended action against the officer for this ‘illegal’ order.

The Bar Council of India has recently notified the Certificate of Practice and Renewal Rules of 2014. Under these rules, a lawyer must practice for two years in a trial court and three in a high court before being allowed to practice before the apex court. The new rules also mandate the renewal of licenses every five years, in an attempt to “weed out” those lawyers who are no longer practicing.

In accordance with the Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act, the Ministry of Law and Justice has decided on the formation of a separate High Court for Andhra Pradesh. According to section 30 of the A.P. Reorganisation Act, 2014 the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad shall be the common High Court for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh till a separate High Court for the State of Andhra Pradesh is constituted under Article 214 of the Constitution of India and other provisions of the Act.


The National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority (NPPA) is all set to slash the prices of popular medicines for stress, hypertension, HIV, pain and pneumonia. The move seeks to cover as many as 100 new drugs and would apply to drugs of varying strengths. This is the second time that NPPA has proposed regulating the price of drugs outside the National List of Essential Medicines (NLEM), 2011. The announcement by NPPA comes in light of its findings that certain “anomalies or discrepancies” exist in the description/specification of drugs in NLEM.

We hope that this summarizes the last week's News. Your comments and suggestions are welcomed.
Until next post of weekly News updates.

Anjana Srinivasan, (2nd Year student of IIT Kharagpur Law School)

For 'OFF Court.'

Disclaimer: This blog or any post thereof is not to be considered to be in any way associated with the official stand of IIT kharagpur or RGSOIPL on the issues being discussed in the said post. The opinions on the blog are the authors own and should not be considered as legal advice.

Wednesday, 12 November 2014

Of Assignments, Licenses and other Demons thereof

Author: Narayanan MH, 3rd Year student of IIT Law School, IIT Kharagpur

The title of this blog post amuses the author as much as it amuses its readers, as the author during his initial year in law school always got confronted by one question,
“What is the difference between an agreement and a contract?”

Being from a non legal family background the author answered:
“Section 2(h) of Indian Contract Act: an agreement enforceable by law is a contract”

But nearing the last few months of his legal studies, after few fruitful classes, discussions, and internships, the author learned that it is not as simple as stating section 2(h).

The author considers the Contract Act, 1872, to be one of the essential guide for a law student to begin his/her/third gender’s (Supreme Court now recognizes them) legal journey and hence would like to share his limited understanding of the answer to the above question before venturing into the title.

In layman’s words section 2 states that a Person A who for the purpose of getting assent of Person B proposes to do an act (includes abstinence) and Person B accepts it, then Person A becomes the promisor and Person B becomes the promisee. The accepted proposal becomes a promise.
For example the owner of this blog offering the author to publish his article and the author accepting the proposal makes it a promise.
Section 2(d) states consideration as an act, abstinence or promise of the promisee—Person B (past, present and future of doing) at the desire of promisor—Person A.
 

If a promise accepted by Person B has a counterpart of consideration to Person A it is an agreement. (Section 2(e)).
Continuing with the example stated above the author agreeing to pay Rs. 200  as publishing charge to the owner of blog makes the promise an agreement and the promise or act of paying Rs. 200 becomes consideration.

Now that agreement is understood the important section for understanding the meaning the section 2(h) (legally enforceable agreements) is section 10 of the Contract Act.
Section 10 seeks compliance of 4 conditions from an agreement to make it a contract:
·           Free consent (Section 14)
·           Competency of Parties (Section 11)
·           Lawful consideration (Section 23)
·           Lawful object. (Section 23)

Both the author and the blog owner are of legal age (competent) and gave free consent for the agreement. Hence, it is now enforceable by law becoming a contract. If the author does not pay Rs. 200 to the blog owner after this article gets published then the blog owner can move the court to enforce the contract.

From the above explanation, the author understood the difficulty in comprehending one of the shortest bare acts in law school and hence restricts himself to the question without going into further legal intricacies like consensus adidum, if the readers are interested they can do research on the following questions:

       Difference between void, voidable and illegal agreements and contracts?
       Difference between a deed and an agreement?

Coming back to the title, hindu mythology being one of the most fascinating mythologies of the world often portrayed demons as powerful as gods. In one such mythology, demons have the power of rising from the blood spilled from another demon and also have the power to deceive the seer. But the seer can find the demons if he knows what to look for amidst their varied appearances, hence the use of demons in the title.

The motive of the author here is to make the reader aware of these demons namely, assignments and license and their ability to deceive the seer.
Now that the author has researched and wrote this article, he cannot just like that give away this article to the blog owner for publication without being aware of his rights. The author by virtue of Copyright Act, section 14 has several rights from now on called “Bundle of Rights” (as used by the author’s Copyright law professor).

The 200 rupees given to the blog owner has 20-10 rupees note, likewise the bundle of rights have many individual rights like right to communication to public, right to translate, right to sell copies etc.
Assignments, licenses are the instruments used to legally transfer/permit the others to use one’s right.
License can be simply termed as permission from the way it is used in daily life like driving license, shop license etc. When a license is granted the main thing to be remembered is the licensee is not the owner, he just has permission to use the right.

If the author permits the blog owner to publish this article in his blog, the blog owner can do so only in this blog, while the author holds the rights to publish this article anywhere else.
Assignment on the other hand is assigning a right, if the author assigns the right to publish to this blog owner, then the author can never publish this article anywhere, but that does not take away the authors other rights in the bundle.
Thus, the essential elements in understanding licenses and assignments are that there are multiple rights, they can be either assigned fully or grant permission to others to use.

The reader must also note that there can be many varieties of this assignments and licenses based on the term of the contract like time, name of right, area, and others.
As an end to this article the author would term contract law as ‘Nothing’ with two quotes.

Quote 1: “You ain't seen nothin' yet.”  -AL JOLSON

Quote 2: “Nothing is an awe-inspiring yet essentially undigested concept, highly esteemed by writers of an existentialist tendency, but by most others regarded with anxiety, nausea, or panic.” - P. L. HEATH- 

Disclaimer: This blog or any post thereof is not to be considered to be in any way associated with the official stand of IIT kharagpur or RGSOIPL on the issues being discussed in the said post. The opinions on the blog are the authors own and should not be considered as legal advice.

Sunday, 9 November 2014

Legal Updates



We bring you the updates for last week. Hope it updates you with all the news from legal world.

Updates: 2nd November to 8th November 2014.


2nd November:

Delhi Police has approached the Supreme Court with the plea to modify the December 2013 order in which the Apex Court had said, “The men in uniform; operational agencies which require unhindered access to roads for performance of their duty; those engaged in emergency duties such as ambulance services, fire services, emergency maintenance etc.; and, police vehicles used as escorts or pilots or for law and order duties shall not be entitled to have red light but lights of other colours, eg, blue, white, multi-coloured etc.” The Supreme Court had ordered on 2nd November that only “high dignitaries” can use the red beacon, and only when on duty.

3rd November:

The CIC, Prof M Sridhar Acharyulu, held on 3rd November 2014 that ‘charge-sheet’ has to be disclosed after separating non-disclosable portions, if any, as per restrictions prescribed under RTI Act. The CIC was hearing an appeal by Ms. Usha Kanth Asiwal who sought to know of complaint (charge-sheet) made to Anti Corruption Bureau on 25-04-2001 and  inquiry leading to registration of case against 13 persons under Prevention of Corruption Act, which is now under prosecution in Tis Hazari Courts.

Roche and Cipla have failed to reach an agreement over the Erlotinib patent dispute. At the instance of Delhi High Court, in around April this year, Roche and Cipla got engage in mediation. The mediator submitted the failure report after discussions between the two parties failed to fructify. It was highly suspected that any compromise may happen considering the nature of the dispute and patent at stake. The proceeding will now resume in Delhi High Court.

Cipla has brazenly launched a cheaper generic version of Novartis’ Indacetorol (a drug used to treat chronic obstructive pulmonary disease). Cipla has further petitioned to the DIPP to revoke to revoke Novartis’ patents in public interest under S.66 of the Indian patent act. This would be the first time when a plea for revocation of patent will be entertained solely on the ground of public interest.  Cipla has taken two grounds for revocation that it is very costly and that it is not sufficiently produced in India, thus it is pre-judicial to the public.

4th November:

The decision rendered by a division bench of Justice Mukta Gupta and Justice Pradeep Nadrajog in a rape case has been a highlight this week in all forms of media. The accused Achey Lal was acquitted of the offences of murder and rape in view that the prosecution was not able to prove its case ‘beyond reasonable doubt’ that the accused has committed the offence so charged against him. The controversy that arouse is mostly because the judgment spoke of the deceased aged 65-70 is beyond the age of menopause and any sexual intercourse, which is forceful and not forcible, is not rape.

It has recently come to the notice of the Indian Government that a German company is using the term ‘khadi’ in its trademark. Khadi being a popular symbol in     India, mostly because of Gandhian Movement and has established itself as Swaraj and Self-sufficiency during Indian Freedom Fight. The German company, ‘Khadi Naturprodukte’ is in the business of selling various Indian-origin products such as shampoos, soaps and oils in Europe. Incidentally, these are products which Khadi and Village Industries Commission (KVIC), an arm of the Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME), sells in addition to fabric. This will open a new gate for the Government of India to protect its IP across the seas. It is also note-worthy that a GI application on Khadi is also on the way.

5th November:

Release of ‘Rang rasiya’, a movie directed by Ketan Mehta claimed to be based on the life of renowned painter Raja Ravi Varma has been stayed by the Mavelikkara munsiff court in Alapuzha district in Kerala. She had stated that the film is depicting a false image of the artist and she called the movie a ‘direct assault’ on Indian culture and womanhood. She also alleged the violation of the Copyright Act, 1957.

Justice D. Hariparanthaman of the Madras High Court has ruled that a married daughter of a deceased government employee is eligible for appointment under compassionate grounds. The Court ruled, “There cannot be any discrimination between a married son and a married daughter. Making discrimination between a son and a daughter on the ground of marriage is arbitrary and violative of fundamental right to equality.”

The Economic Times reports that Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP) has set up a think tank to advise the Government on a gamut of issues related to patents and to also draft a national IPR policy. The think-tank is a six member panel headed by Justice Prabha Sridevan, a former judge (Madras High Court) and former chairperson of the Intellectual Property Appellate Board (IPAB). This is a follow up step of  bilateral US-India Trade Policy Forum announced by Narendra Modi and Barack Obama.

7th November:

The Supreme Court has demanded details from the Central Government with respect to individuals residing in Government accommodations. It urged the Government to render information regarding the categories of bungalows existing in Delhi, their allotment under discretionary and people who have been overstaying in the same. On vacation of government bungalows by judges of the apex court and HCs, the bench said, “Judges of any forum shall vacate the official residence within a period of one month from the date of superannuation/retirement. However, after recording sufficient reason(s), the time may be extended by another month.”

The SC ruled that the judiciary cannot direct the government to conduct census ina particular manner and that would amount to ‘colossal transgression’ of the power of judicial review, thus overruling the Madras HC judgment in which Hon’ble HC had directed the central govt to conduct  caste based census.  Three judge bench categorically ruled that issuing a mandamus directing the State to conduct census in a particular manner would be in excess of its power of judicial re view. The Hon’ble SC held that “The order is exceptionally cryptical. That apart, it is legally wholly unsustainable.  The High Court, to say the least, had no justification to pave such a path and we have no hesitation in treating the said path as a colossal transgression of power of judicial review, and that makes the order sensitively susceptible.”

The European Patent Office (EPO) announced on its website today that it has entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the Intellectual Property Office of India (IPO India) on co-operation on patents to promote innovation in India and the European Union. The MoU calls for bilateral co-operation between EPO & IPO and it seeks to establish a framework for structured work relations between both the offices for a minimum of four years.

The Delhi High Court in Sukesh Behl v. Koninklijke Phillips Electronics (Division Bench. Maj. Behl Vs Philips-DB1-DHC 7.11.2014) passed a significant decision with regard to Section 8 of the Patent Act 1970. It ruled that a patentee’s non compliance with Section 8 of the Patent Act will not lead to an automatic revocation of its patent under Section 64(1)(m). As per the decision, it is necessary to check whether the omission to disclose information under Section 8 was deliberate/intentional or whether it was a mere clerical/bona fide error.

We hope that this summarizes the last week's News. Your comments and suggestions are welcomed.
Until next post of weekly News updates.

Manish Kumar, (3rd Year student of IIT Kharagpur Law School)

For 'OFF Court.'

Disclaimer: This blog or any post thereof is not to be considered to be in any way associated with the official stand of IIT kharagpur or RGSOIPL on the issues being discussed in the said post. The opinions on the blog are the authors own and should not be considered as legal advice.

Sunday, 2 November 2014

Legal Updates

We bring you the updates for last week. Hope it updates you with all the news from legal world.



Updates: 26th October to 1st November 2014.

The National Commission for Women will be a placing a proposal before a panel constituted by the Supreme Court on November 8 for legalizing prostitution in India..  The apex court had constituted the panel after a public interest litigation was filed in 2010 on rehabilitation of sex workers. The panel will deliberate on the existing provision of Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956 (ITPA). The deliberations would focus on improved conditions that would allow sex workers to lead a dignified life. But activists have voiced their concerns over the NCW’s proposal. The legalization of prostitution goes against the ILO’s definition of ‘decent work’.

A man was arrested by cops for allegedly having sex with another man, which was recorded by his wife on a hidden camera. The man has been arrested under Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code that makes it an offense to commit 'carnal intercourse against the order of nature.' The highly debated re-instatement of the clause by the Supreme Court which was previously struck down by the Delhi HC as unconstitutional makes gay sex an offence punishable with life imprisonment.

The Supreme Court has rejected the plea by Nithari killer Surinder Koli seeking recall of the judgment upholding his death sentence in Rimpa Haldar murder case.

While applying for a passport for her child, an unwed mother will have to declare how she conceived. This was the Union Government’s reply to a query by a division bench of the Bombay HC that was hearing a petition by a woman challenging the passport authority's refusal to include her step-father's name in her passport. According to the advocate appearing on behalf of the foreign ministry, a unwed mother should file an affidavit stating ‘how she has conceived’ and ‘if she was raped’ and why she does not want the father's name included.

The CIC has held that the husband had a right to know about the amount of salary of the wife but information pertaining to expenditures and loan deductions cannot be given under the RTI Act. Amount of salary and the details of pay scale of a public servant can be a part of voluntarily disclosable information under Section 4(1)(b) but deductions, personal loans, seeking salary slips and residential address are not disclosable unless a public interest is involved.

The Delhi University will soon have its own IP policy. The IP policy will look into the patentability of the research undertaken by the students and staffs, the registration of copyright and trademark by the DU.  As per the university statistics, 168 patents are registered by Delhi University, 71 patents are under prosecution, 35 patents have been granted and 52 patent applications have lapsed.

The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India recently issued a notification introducing a requirement that the pictorial and textual statutory warnings must cover 85% of the display area of the package. The notification, that amends the Cigarettes and Other Tobacco Products (Packaging and Labelling Rules), 2008 specifies that the pictorial warning must cover at least 60% of the area and the textual warning 25% percent of the area of the package—on both sides of the package. This move by the Government seems to be a plain packaging requirement though it is not in the purest form as in other countries like Australia and some European countries.


The US Eleventh Circuit Court has come out with a landmark ruling on the legality of course packs involving Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press and Sage Publications against Georgia State University. GSU was indulging in digital dissemination of  course packs allowing students to obtain a digital copy of the designated course material. The Court held that the thought the excerpts were not transformative they were for a non-profitable educative purpose and it constituted fair use, despite the non-transformative nature.


We hope that this summarizes the last week's News. Your comments and suggestions are welcomed.
Until next post of weekly News updates.

Anjana Srinivasan, (2nd Year student of IIT Kharagpur Law School)

For 'OFF Court.'

Disclaimer: This blog or any post thereof is not to be considered to be in any way associated with the official stand of IIT kharagpur or RGSOIPL on the issues being discussed in the said post. The opinions on the blog are the authors own and should not be considered as legal advice.



Thursday, 30 October 2014

The Art of Secularism

Author: Antriksh Mishra, 3rd Year student of IIT Law School, IIT Kharagpur.

"India is my country and I am proud to be its citizen"—one thing which no Indian will think twice before speaking. Now let’s change the parameters a little–"Hinduism is my religion and I am proud to be a Hindu." Now that is something people think twice before speaking. It has happened to me and to many others I know. 

In this post I would try to dwell the reasons for such hesitation. Let’s begin with Art. 25 of the Constitution of India, the famous "Freedom of Religion" clause. Firstly the clause allows "all persons" to "practice", "profess" and "propagate" their religion. This would include all individuals whether or not citizens of India.



The words "practice", "profess" and "propagate" cover any and all religious activities, even asking other persons to join your religion (as long as such joining is without force or consideration) is allowed (as mentioned by K. Santhanam during the Constituent Assembly Debates). And this beckons the question, "Why the hesitation?"

One might say that the answer is more of a psychological nature than legal. I would however respectfully disagree. The answer is more related to Indian Polity and Law than to Psychology.

Let’s start from the common understanding of the word secular and try to answers some fundamental questions.

1. Is being secular the anti-thesis of being religious?

The answer to this is a quite emphatic “No”. If being secular were the anti-thesis of being religious, both of these could not have found place in our Constitution. Secularism as referred to in the Preamble and religious freedom as referred to in Art. 25, as propounded by The Keshvananda Bharti Judgement, find their place in the basic structure of the Constitution. (Notwithstanding my objection on the way the Keshvananda Judgement was delivered, and how Justice HR Khanna's opinion was not similar to that of the other three majority judges, It is still the law of the land.)

2. Does being religious mean you must follow all preaching of a faith?

Again the answer would be an emphatic a “NO”. Take for example Galileo or Darwin, both of them asked questions and were subjected to great persecution, but today Christianity has evolved and accepted (to a certain extent) their theories, while they were devoted Christians till their dying breath. Now for the legal stand lets read Art 19 and Art 25 together, I have the right to free speech (which allows me any question on any religion) and Freedom of religion (which gives me freedom to choose religion), so no one has the right to doubt one’s faith in a religion, or stop him from practicing a religion based on questions raised by a follower. Religion (in theory) must welcome and clear doubts.

3. When one calls oneself proud to be of the Hindu faith does he become a zealot?

And again the answer is  a ”NO”. What faith you follow is a personal question, whether you choose to be vocal about it is a personal choice. As long as you don't hurt another faith how can there be a question of being a zealot. And this is where Politics comes into the picture. Hinduism in India seems to have become synonymous of RSS or BJP or the Babri Masjid incident. But frankly it is not. Not withstanding the fact that RSS ( the then Hindu Mahasabha) was the only organization other than the Muslim league to not take part in the Quit India movement and their chief in 2006 claimed that Quit India Movement was a failure.  In all fairness the public services done by RSS, Hinduism and Hindu extremists are two different things,just as Muslims are different from Muslim extremist. One does not equate the practices in Muslim majority State of Turkey to that of Saudi Arabia then why isn't such a differentiation available for the Hindu faith. As per the principle of equity Hindus have the same rights and responsibilities as the other minority classes in India. And by virtue of being the majority, the Constitution does not bestow upon them, a higher degree of responsibilities than the other faiths.


I am proud to say that I am religious, I am proud to say I am a Hindu and I am proud to say that I am a Bhartiya, an Indian, a Hindustani (which is actually derived from Indus, but Hey! propaganda is spread by use of selective dissemination of facts, as recently) and still I am secular. I respect other faiths, I ask questions about other’s and my own faith and I wish to leave my faith to future generations, evolved, than what it was when I had it. In this regard I agree with Mahatma Gandhi's views.



Disclaimer: This blog or any post thereof is not to be considered to be in any way associated with the official stand of IIT kharagpur or RGSOIPL on the issues being discussed in the said post. The opinions on the blog are the authors own and should not be considered as legal advice.


Sunday, 26 October 2014

Legal Updates

We bring you the updates for last week. Hope it updates you with all the news from legal world.

Updates: 19th October to 25th October 2014.

In a case by one Gursahani, the SEBI’s circular increasing the limitation for arbitration from six months to three years was challenged. The court upheld the circular and dismissed the case.

In Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd. Vs.  Novartis AG, Suit seeking permanent injunction restraining the appellant from infringing respondents Indian Patent came up for preliminary consideration before the learned Single Judge on September 08, 2014, on which date the appellant appeared to oppose the grant of any ad-interim injunction. The Court said that no ad-interim injunction can be given on lines of LA Roche Ltd. & Anr. Vs. Cipla Ltd.

The Chief Information Officer, Prof M Sridhar Acharyulu, took a strict stance on the handling and weeding out policies of government documents subject to RTIs. The Commission looking into the matter asked the concerned authority to show cause to show cause why maximum penalty cannot be imposed on him for making a wrong claim of weeding the record and for not furnishing the information to the complainant. The direction of the Commission clearly reflects the harmony between Public Records Act and Right to Information Act.

After coming out on bail, Jayalalitha took notice of the extreme steps being taken in row of the Court’s decision. She has appealed to all the supporters to condemn such acts and has promised Rs. 3 Lacs compensation to the families of the deceased. A responsible gesture by the ex-CM, but it would have been prudent to take such a stance much earlier.

In the infamous case of alleged sexual harassment in the Madhya Pradesh High Court, the accused administrative Judge has asserted before the apex Court that the woman judge “was not a disciplined member of the judiciary and after an elapsation of 15 days after the glory of the post she had formerly held, she levied reckless allegations and concocted a story in an attempt to get herself reinstated in service”. The course ahead depends crucially on the evidence advanced before the Court for efficient dispense of justice.

The All Inida Bar Association (AIBA) has written to the Supreme Court to initiate suo moto contempt proceedings against Thanti TV, a Tamil news channel. The channel is alleged to have recorded the court proceedings of the arguments put forward by Mr. Fali Nariman in the  Jayalalitha case.  Amid all this, the Kerala High Court is discussing provisions to ban lawyers from talking to journalists about their pending cases and their proceedings.

According to the direction by the law ministry, all 15,000 subordinate courts will have their judgments digitised, with new judgments to be uploaded by 6pm on the day that it is handed down. This is a welcome step which should have seen the light of the day years ago for efficient administration of the Court proceedings.

According to the direction by the Government, all its ministries will have to upload all the RTI applications and their respective replies on their websites. This documents containing personal information can be put out of the ambit of this direction. This is a potential step towards greater transparency and efficiency.

In the alleged forest land encroachment by BS Yedurappa and his kin, the Karnataka High Court set aside the Sessions court order which was stalling the investigation. The estimated area encroached is around 84 acres in the Shimoga district. With all relevant documents submitted and arguments completed, the decision will be given on 28th October.

The deadline of the biometric attendance system kicks in on the 25th of this month. According to the direction from the PMO, all the government offices are to be installed with the electronic attendance machines. Also, the attendance is accessible to the public through attendance.gov.in. This is a simple step taken by the Government to ensure efficient governance and better service.

We hope that this summarizes the last week's News. Your comments and suggestions are welcomed.
Until next post of weekly News updates.

Abhishek Chansoria (1st Year student of IIT Kharagpur Law School)

For 'OFF Court.'

Disclaimer: This blog or any post thereof is not to be considered to be in any way associated with the official stand of IIT kharagpur or RGSOIPL on the issues being discussed in the said post. The opinions on the blog are the authors own and should not be considered as legal advice.


Sunday, 19 October 2014

Legal Updates


In this new feature of our blog, we will be bringing you all that has happened in the legal world last week. We hope that the augmentation of these news will be helpful for all of us in updating ourselves.

Updates: 13th October to 18th October 2014.
The Last week started with the SEBI barring DLF and six executives from entering the securities market and from buying or selling securities for three years. This follows the failure of DLF to provide key information on subsidiaries and pending legal cases at the time of its 2007 public offering. This might be a crucial decision taken by SEBI and it remains to be seen what course the court takes on this issue.

The Delhi High Court laid down guidelines in examining child witnesses when it overruled a judgment of the Dwarka District Court acquitting the accused in the rape of a 3 year old girl. The Court referred to Section 118 of the Indian Evidence Act, which states that the testimony of a child can be considered as a basis of conviction provided the child understands the questions. The Court criticized the approach of the trial court which had held the testimony of the child to be inadmissible.

AIADMK supporters had a reason to cheer and celebrate as the Supreme Court granted bail to the party supremo J. Jayalalitha and suspended the trial court’s sentence on a condition that there will be no attempt to delay the criminal proceedings in the Karnataka High Court. There can be different stands of legal scholars on this but as for the courts are concerned, they would take reason and practicality in accord for now.

The CIC has held that during the pendency of a RTI application the relevant record should not be destroyed by the public authority even if it’s weeding out policy permits. The CIC has cautioned that such a destruction of record would be a serious breach of the Right to Information Act.

India says no to unilateral opinion. The Government of India has told the American authorities that they will not be co-operating USTR’s Special 301 Out of Cycle Review (OCR) process. Indian authorities have said that they would engage US in bi-lateral dialogue mechanisms under the new IP working group, rather than the unilateral process.

The e-commerce business and its meaning and limits are being tested in the courts now. In the last week development, the famous WWE (World Wrestling Entertainment, Inc.) filed suit of infringement and passing off against an Indian company. The question that was settled was regarding the ‘carries on business’ in cases of e-commerce. The Delhi High Court has concluded that the jurisdiction will be determined by the buyer’s place of residence. This was supported by the interpretation of section 134(2) of The Trademark Act and section 62(2) of The Copyright Act along with section 4 (“contracts would be completed at the place where the acceptance is communicated.”) of the Indian Contract Act.

And here is some new for the ‘firsts’. The Controller General of Patents Designs and Trademarks recently launched a couple of features on online search services for patents and trademarks to make the search process easier and provide transparent results. The features include innovative tools such as “Stock and Flow”—a utility which existed for trademarks, has now been extended to patents also. The Indian Patent Office is the first in the world to achieve such transparency.

Now, its time for some filmy news. The Allahabad High Court has issued a notice to the makers of the film ‘Haider’ on a PIL filed by the Hindu Front for justice on the grounds that the movie was against national interests. The petitioner have criticized that the movie shows the Indian Army in poor light and song sequence was shot in the Markand Sun Temple with actors dancing with their footwear.

Red Chillies Entertainments Private Limited’s film ‘Happy New Year’, starring Deepika Padukone and Shah Rukh Khan which is set to release in theatres across India on 24th October, has recently obtained a John Doe order from the Bombay High Court dated 14th October. It will be interesting to follow this case for what remains to be a potential area of IP.

We hope that this summarizes the last week legal News. Your comments and suggestions are welcomed.
Until next post of weekly News updates.

Anjana Srinivasan, (2nd Year student of IIT Kharagpur Law School)

For 'OFF Court.'